How a bank creates money when it lends Image: Steve Daniels, CC BY-SA 2.0

How a bank creates money when it lends

Ask most people how a bank works and they will describe a warehouse. Savers bring money in, the bank keeps a little in the vault and lends the rest to borrowers, and the interest it charges borrowers pays the interest it owes savers. The picture is in many textbooks, and it is wrong in one important respect. In 2014 the Bank of England published an article called Money creation in the modern economy in its Quarterly Bulletin that said so in plain words: in a modern economy most money is created by commercial banks when they make loans.

What counts as money

Start with what money is. Notes and coins are money, and so is the balance in your current account, because you can pay for things with it. The Bank of England's article gives the figures for the United Kingdom: about 97 per cent of the money held by households and firms was bank deposits and about 3 per cent was currency. The shares are similar in the euro area and the United States. The money most of us use is therefore a number in a bank's computer, a liability of the bank to us, and the question of how money is created is the question of how those numbers come into being.

The T-account

A balance sheet in its simplest form has assets on the left and liabilities on the right, and the two sides always add to the same total. Take a bank with 100 million euros of reserves at the central bank and 900 million of loans on the asset side, and 950 million of customer deposits and 50 million of shareholders' equity on the liability side. Now a customer asks for a mortgage of 200,000 euros to buy a flat, and the bank agrees.

What happens is two entries. On the asset side the bank records a new loan of 200,000 euros, which is the customer's promise to repay. On the liability side it adds 200,000 euros to the customer's deposit account. Nothing has been taken from any other account, no saver's money has been moved, and the bank's reserves have not changed. The balance sheet has grown by 200,000 euros on both sides, and the economy has 200,000 euros more money in it than it had a minute before, because a deposit that did not exist now does. When the customer pays the seller of the flat, the deposit moves to the seller's bank, and the bank settles the transfer with reserves, but the new deposit still exists somewhere in the system. When the loan is repaid, the entries are reversed and the money is destroyed.

That is the whole mechanism, and the textbook story has the causation backwards. Banks do not wait for deposits in order to lend; lending creates the deposits. Unit 9 of the masterclass works through this example in T-accounts, follows the deposit when it leaves the bank, and then asks the question that follows at once.

What stops them creating money without limit?

If a loan creates its own funding, why does a bank not lend without end? The Bank of England's article lists the constraints, and they are real. The first is profitability. A loan is only worth making if the borrower is likely to repay with interest, so the demand for loans from creditworthy borrowers at the going interest rate sets an upper bound. The second is the need to settle. When the new deposit leaves for another bank, the lending bank must hand over reserves, and if it lends much faster than its competitors it will run short of reserves and have to borrow them, in the interbank market or from the central bank, at a cost. The third is regulation. Capital rules require that a bank's equity be at least a given fraction of its risk-weighted assets, and liquidity rules require it to hold enough assets that can be sold quickly; both limit how far the balance sheet can grow for a given amount of shareholders' money. The fourth is the central bank's policy rate, which sets the cost of the reserves a bank needs and therefore the interest rate it must charge, which feeds back into how many borrowers want loans.

The old textbook had its own constraint, the money multiplier: banks keep a fraction of deposits as reserves, the central bank fixes the quantity of reserves, and the money stock is the reserves divided by the fraction. The arithmetic is fine as an upper bound, and Unit 9 states it as one. As a description of what central banks do it stopped being accurate decades ago. Central banks today set an interest rate and supply whatever reserves the banking system needs at that rate, so reserves follow lending rather than leading it. When the Bank of England created hundreds of billions of pounds of reserves through quantitative easing after 2009, bank lending did not rise in proportion, which is what one would expect if reserves were never the binding constraint.

A worked number

Suppose a bank's regulators require equity of at least 8 per cent of risk-weighted assets, and that a mortgage carries a risk weight of 35 per cent, as it does for a standard residential loan under the Basel rules. A mortgage of 200,000 euros then counts as 70,000 euros of risk-weighted assets and requires 5,600 euros of equity behind it. A bank with 50 million euros of equity and no other business could therefore have at most about 1.8 billion euros of such mortgages on its books, a ratio of 36 to 1 between loans and the shareholders' own money. In practice banks hold more capital than the minimum, and their loan books are a mixture of assets with different weights, but the example shows why the capital rules, rather than the deposits in the vault, are what a bank's treasurer watches.

Why the distinction matters

It matters for understanding crises. If banks lent out savers' money, a bank could never lend more than had been saved and credit booms would be impossible. Because banks create deposits when they lend, the quantity of credit can run far ahead of the real economy, as it did in Ireland and Spain in the 2000s, and the money created in a boom is destroyed in the bust when loans are written off or repaid and not replaced. It matters for monetary policy, because a central bank steers the economy through the price of reserves and the willingness of banks to lend, which is a slower and less certain lever than turning a tap on the money supply. And it matters for the public debate, in which the phrase printing money is often applied to things that are nothing of the kind.

Unit 9 of the masterclass, Money, Banks, and Central Banks, builds the balance sheets step by step, explains reserves and the policy rate, and then turns to the one way in which a bank can be destroyed by the deposits it has created, which is the subject of another post on this blog. The weekly dataset for that unit is the ECB Data Portal, where you can read the money stock of the euro area and see for yourself what share of it is cash.

Study the economy properly

The Economics Masterclass: weekly units, quizzes, a final exam, and a certificate.
About the program