Market Power and Strategy
A firm with no rivals sets its own price, and a firm with a few rivals must guess theirs. This unit derives the monopolist's price and the deadweight loss it causes, ties the mark-up to the elasticity of demand, explains why cinemas charge students less, and uses game theory to show why cartels break down and how many firms a market needs before it behaves competitively. It ends with the Herfindahl-Hirschman index and the work of competition authorities, from Standard Oil in 1911 to Google Shopping in 2017.
In December 2013 a new pill against hepatitis C came onto the American market at a list price of 1,000 US dollars a pill, which is 84,000 dollars for the twelve weeks that cure most patients, while the chemicals in the whole treatment cost about 100 dollars to make. Nothing in Unit 4 allows such a gap, because a price-taking firm that charged more than the cost of one more item would lose every customer to a rival. The firm that sold the pill had no rival, and this unit is about firms in that position, about firms with only a few rivals who watch each other’s prices, and about the authorities whose job it is to keep both in check.
1 Where market power comes from
A firm has market power when it can raise its price above the cost of one more item without losing all its customers. In the competitive industry of Unit 4 no firm has it, because the product is the same everywhere and buyers can switch at no cost. Market power needs something that stops other firms from entering and competing the price back down. Economists call such obstacles barriers to entry, and five kinds account for most cases:
- Scale. Where average cost keeps falling up to an output that is a large share of the whole market, one large firm produces more cheaply than two medium ones, and a newcomer that starts small cannot match the cost of the firm that is already there; a town has one water network for this reason.
- Control of an input. A firm that owns the only deposit, the only harbour, or the only landing slots at an airport can keep rivals out by keeping the input.
- Patents and copyright. A patent gives its holder the exclusive right to make and sell an invention, in most countries for 20 years from the application, which is how the maker of the hepatitis C pill could charge what it charged. Copyright does the same for books, music, and software.
- Network effects. A telephone, a payment card, or a social network is worth more to each user the more other users it has, so an established network with many users is hard to challenge even with a better product.
- Government licences. Taxi licences, broadcasting frequencies, pharmacies in some countries, and the postal monopoly of many states limit entry by law.
How much power a firm has depends on how many rivals it has and on how different their products are. Economists sort markets into four types by these two features, and the sorting is used throughout the rest of the unit.
The first structure was the subject of Unit 4, and this unit takes the other three, starting with the monopolist, who need only look at its customers, and moving to the oligopolist, who must also look at its rivals.