Two tall smoke stacks of a power plant in Brooklyn seen from above, with smoke drifting across the roof of the plant, photographed in 1973
Unit 06 · All masterclasses · 60 min

Market Failure and Public Policy

Externalities, public goods, hidden information, and what policy can do
Image: Chester Higgins, Jr., US National Archives, public domain

A competitive market makes the total surplus as large as possible only under conditions that pollution, lighthouses, overfished seas, and used cars all break. This unit measures the loss when a factory does not pay for its smoke, derives the tax that removes it, shows why a market for the right to pollute cut American sulfur emissions by two thirds at a fraction of the expected cost, explains why nobody pays for a lighthouse and why the Newfoundland cod disappeared, and follows Akerlof's lemons into the insurance market. It ends with the costs of intervening and with the social cost of carbon, the most argued-over number in economics.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

Unit 2 showed that a competitive market in equilibrium leaves no gain from trade unused, and Unit 4 showed why free entry pushes the price down to the cost of one more item. Both results hold only under conditions that are easy to overlook. The buyer and the seller of a tonne of coal-fired electricity are not the only people the deal touches, because the sulfur and the carbon dioxide from the chimney fall on everyone else. Nobody owns the cod in the sea, so nobody has a reason to leave any for next year. The seller of a used car knows things about it that the buyer does not. This unit is about the ways in which the welfare result fails, about what taxes, rules, and new markets can do in each case, and about the costs of doing it.

1 What the welfare result assumes

The result of Unit 2 was that the equilibrium quantity of a competitive market makes the total surplus of buyers and sellers as large as it can be, because every item up to the equilibrium quantity is worth more to its buyer than it costs its seller, and every item beyond it would cost more than it is worth. Economists call this result the first welfare theorem, and like every theorem it holds only under its conditions.

When one of the conditions fails and the market left to itself produces too much, too little, or the wrong thing, economists speak of a market failure. Prices still form and goods still change hands, but the quantity at which the market settles is not the one that makes the surplus largest. Market power, the failure of the first condition, was the subject of Unit 5. This unit takes the other three in turn: externalities, public goods and common resources, and hidden information. Each section asks how large the loss is and what a government can do about it at a cost below the loss.

The full unit is part of the program

Want to see a complete unit first? Unit 2, Supply, Demand, and Market Equilibrium, is free to read.