Aerial view of the container port of Miami, with a container ship under gantry cranes and the city skyline in the distance
Unit 11 · Advanced and Advanced + Behavioural Economics · 65 min

International Trade and Exchange Rates

Why countries trade, who gains, and what an exchange rate measures
Image: James R. Tourtellotte, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The unit opens the border. It shows with Ricardo's principle why a country gains from trade even when it is worse at producing everything, where comparative advantage comes from and why Germany and France sell each other cars, who loses when a country opens up and how slowly the China shock passed, what a tariff does and who paid the tariffs of 2018, why a current account deficit is a loan rather than a loss, and how the nominal and the real exchange rate, purchasing power parity, and the policy trilemma fit together.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

In July 2026 a Big Mac cost 145 Egyptian pounds in Cairo, which was 2.87 US dollars at the exchange rate of the day, and 7.30 Swiss francs in Zurich, which was 9.04 dollars. The same sandwich, made to the same recipe, sold for three times the price in one city as in the other. Between those two numbers lies most of this unit: why countries trade at all, who gains and who loses when they do, what a tariff does to the people who pay it, why a country can import more than it exports year after year without going bankrupt, and what an exchange rate measures. Units 2 and 3 supplied the market diagram and the idea of incidence, Unit 7 the national accounts, and Units 9 and 10 interest rates and the short run.

1 Why countries trade

1.1 Absolute and comparative advantage

Adam Smith (1723-1790) gave the first answer to the question why countries trade in 1776, in his book The Wealth of Nations. If Portugal makes wine with fewer hours of work than England, and England makes cloth with fewer hours than Portugal, each country should make what it makes best and buy the rest. A country that produces a good with less labour than another has an absolute advantage in that good. The answer is right as far as it goes, but it leaves a hard case open. What if one country is better at making everything?

David Ricardo (1772-1823) answered the hard case in 1817, and his answer is the most important result of this unit. What matters is the opportunity cost of a good, which Unit 1 defined as the value of the best alternative forgone. If a car takes 100 hours of labour in a country and a tonne of wheat takes 2 hours, then every car costs that country 50 tonnes of wheat it could have grown instead. A country has a comparative advantage in the good whose opportunity cost is lower at home than abroad, and a country always has a comparative advantage in something, because opportunity costs are ratios, and the opportunity cost of wheat in cars is one over the opportunity cost of cars in wheat, so if cars cost more wheat at home than abroad, wheat must cost fewer cars at home than abroad.

The principle is best seen in numbers. The example below keeps Portugal from Ricardo’s original example, replaces England with Germany, and uses modern goods. Suppose that in Germany a car takes 100 hours of labour and a tonne of wheat 2 hours, and that in Portugal a car takes 250 hours and a tonne of wheat 4 hours. The hours are chosen for the example, and they exaggerate the real gap, because by the World Bank’s figures for 2023 a worker in Germany produced about 1.4 times as much as a worker in Portugal (GDP per person employed, compared at purchasing power parity, an idea that Section 6 explains), not 2 to 2.5 times as much. Give each country one million hours of labour a year. Germany can then make 10,000 cars or 500,000 tonnes of wheat, Portugal 4,000 cars or 250,000 tonnes, and Germany has the absolute advantage in both goods.