Women doing electrical assembly work at the Douglas Aircraft Company plant in Long Beach, California, in 1942
Unit 12 · Advanced and Advanced + Behavioural Economics · 65 min

Labour Markets and Inequality

Wages, human capital, the pay gap, and how inequality is measured
Image: Alfred T. Palmer, Office of War Information, 1942, Library of Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Wages are prices, and this unit treats them as prices set in a market for labour: demand from the value of the marginal product, supply from the choice between work and leisure, and the places where the competitive model fails, above all employers with wage-setting power. It measures the return to a year of schooling, follows the minimum wage debate from New Jersey in 1992 to the bunching studies of the 2010s, decomposes the gender pay gap with Claudia Goldin's work, and then turns to the whole distribution: the Lorenz curve, the Gini coefficient computed from real quintile shares, top income shares since 1913, and Raj Chetty's finding that half of Americans born in the 1980s out-earn their parents, against nine in ten of those born in 1940.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

A plumber in Zurich earns several times what a plumber in Lisbon earns for the same repair, and neither of them chose the figure. Wages are prices, and the first half of this unit treats them as prices, set in a market for labour with a demand side, a supply side, and well documented places where the simple model fails. The second half asks what the resulting distribution of income looks like, how it is measured, how it has changed since 1913, and how far a child’s income is fixed by the income of the parents.

1 The labour market as a market

1.1 Labour demand and the value of the marginal product

A firm hires a worker for what the worker produces. Unit 4 defined the marginal product of labour \(MP_L\) as the extra output from one more worker while the other inputs stay fixed, and found that it falls once the fixed inputs are shared among more people. A firm that sells its output at a given price \(P\) turns this physical quantity into money by multiplying it by the price, and the result is the value of the marginal product, \(VMP_L = P \cdot MP_L\). A profit-maximizing firm hires one more worker as long as that worker brings in more than the wage \(w\) and stops where the two are equal.

The market demand for labour adds up the demand of every firm, and it shifts when anything moves the value of the marginal product: a better oven raises \(MP_L\), a higher price of bread raises \(P\). The same arithmetic answers the question about the two plumbers. The plumber in Zurich works with more and better equipment, which raises \(MP_L\), and serves customers whose own high wages make them willing to pay more for an hour of a service that cannot be imported from a cheaper city, which raises \(P\), as Unit 11 explained for services in general. The two plumbers also do not compete in one market, because people move across borders far less freely than goods do, so nothing pulls the two wages together.

1.2 Labour supply and the equilibrium wage

On the other side of the market, every person decides how many hours to sell. A higher wage makes an hour of leisure more expensive, because it is an hour of pay given up, which pushes people to work more; this is the substitution effect of Unit 3. A higher wage also makes a person richer at any number of hours, and richer people buy more of most things, including leisure, which pushes the other way; this is the income effect of Unit 3. For most people and most wage changes the first effect wins, so the labour supply curve of a market slopes up, and a higher wage also draws in people who were not working at all.

Where the two curves cross, the market clears at the equilibrium wage \(w^{*}\), as in panel (a) of Figure 2. The diagram answers the usual questions. In the model, immigration shifts supply to the right and lowers the wage of the workers the newcomers compete with, although the measured effects in rich countries have been small and are disputed, because newcomers also spend their wages and often fill different jobs. A technology that raises the marginal product of a skill shifts the demand for that skill to the right and raises its wage. A wage held above \(w^{*}\) leaves more people wanting work than firms want to hire. The model is the benchmark of the whole unit, and it rests on assumptions: many firms competing for the same workers, workers who know what other firms pay and can move between them at no cost, and no bargaining.

The full unit is part of the program

Want to see a complete unit first? Unit 2, Supply, Demand, and Market Equilibrium, is free to read.