Image: FBenjr123, CC BY-SA 4.0Who really pays a tax on petrol?
The United Kingdom charges a duty of 52.95 pence on every litre of unleaded petrol, a rate unchanged since March 2022, and then value added tax of 20 per cent on the price including the duty. At a pump price of 1.40 pounds a litre, the duty is 53 pence, the VAT is 23 pence, and the fuel, its transport, and the retailer's margin together account for the remaining 64 pence. The Treasury collects the duty from the companies that release fuel from the refineries and depots, long before a driver sees it. So who pays it?
The wrong question and the right one
The law says who hands the money to the government, and that turns out to be irrelevant to who bears the cost. Suppose the duty were abolished tomorrow and replaced by a duty of the same amount collected from drivers at the pump through a separate machine. Nothing real would change: the same litres would be sold, the same money would reach the Treasury, and the pump price plus the new charge would settle at the same total as before. Economists call this the irrelevance of the statutory incidence, and it is the first thing Unit 2 of the masterclass establishes about a tax. The question that matters is the economic incidence: by how much does the price buyers pay rise, and by how much does the price sellers keep fall?
The diagram answers it. A tax of 53 pence a litre drives a wedge of that size between the two prices. In the diagram with price on the vertical axis and quantity on the horizontal, the wedge sits between the demand curve and the supply curve, and the quantity sold shrinks until the vertical gap between the curves equals the tax. How the wedge is split between a rise in the buyers' price and a fall in the sellers' price depends on the relative slopes of the two curves, and slopes are elasticities in disguise.
The formula
Unit 3 turns the geometry into a formula. Let the price elasticity of demand be the percentage change in the quantity demanded for a one per cent change in price, a negative number, and the price elasticity of supply be the same for the quantity supplied, a positive number. The share of a small tax that buyers pay is the supply elasticity divided by the sum of the supply elasticity and the absolute value of the demand elasticity. The share sellers pay is the rest. The side that can escape more easily, by buying less or selling elsewhere, pays less; the side that cannot escape pays more.
For petrol both elasticities are well studied. Surveys of the research on the demand for motor fuel, which cover hundreds of estimates across countries and decades, put the short-run price elasticity of demand between about −0.1 and −0.3: a 10 per cent rise in the price cuts the quantity bought by 1 to 3 per cent within a year. Over several years, when people can change cars, move house, and change jobs, the elasticity is larger, in the region of −0.6 to −0.8. Demand is inelastic because, in the short run, the car is bought and the commute is fixed.
Supply to one country is a different matter. The United Kingdom buys refined fuel in a world market in which it is a small customer, and a refiner who gets a lower price in Britain can ship the cargo to Rotterdam instead. The supply of fuel to the British market is therefore highly elastic, with estimates of the elasticity in the range of several units, and in the simplest treatment one takes it to be effectively infinite.
The worked number
Take a demand elasticity of −0.25 and a supply elasticity of 2, both defensible for a horizon of a year or so. Buyers' share of the tax is 2 divided by 2.25, which is 0.89. Of the 53 pence of duty, drivers pay about 47 pence through a higher pump price, and the sellers, meaning the refiners, importers, and retailers along the chain, absorb about 6 pence through a lower price before tax. If supply were perfectly elastic, the buyers' share would be 100 per cent and the pump price would carry the whole 53 pence. Drivers' intuition that they pay the duty is therefore roughly right, and it is right because of the elasticities, which means it would stop being right in a market with the opposite shape.
The same formula also tells you how much fuel the duty removes from the road. With a pump price of 1.40 pounds, a duty of 53 pence is about 38 per cent of the price. If the duty were abolished and 89 per cent of it passed through, the pump price would fall by about 47 pence, or a third, and with a demand elasticity of −0.25 the quantity bought would rise by roughly 8 per cent in the short run and perhaps 20 per cent after a few years. The duty raises about 24 billion pounds a year for the Treasury according to its own receipts data; the reduction in fuel use is the part of its effect that a government interested in emissions cares about, and the tax wedge diagram shows both at once.
The opposite case
To see the elasticities working the other way, think of a tax on a good whose supply is fixed and whose buyers have many alternatives. A tax on the rental value of land is the classic example: the quantity of land does not respond to the price, so the supply elasticity is zero, the buyers' share is zero, and landowners bear the whole tax however it is collected. A tax on a particular brand of soft drink, when a dozen untaxed brands sit on the same shelf, falls mostly on the producer, because demand for that one brand is very elastic. Mexico's tax of one peso per litre on sugary drinks from January 2014 and the United Kingdom's levy of 2018 are studied in Unit 3 as cases where the pass-through to shelf prices was measured directly, and the research spotlight of that unit, by Hunt Allcott and his co-authors, works through what the elasticities imply for the design of such a tax.
Three things to remember
Who writes the cheque to the tax office tells you nothing about who pays. The split is decided by the two elasticities, and the inelastic side pays more. And the elasticities change with the horizon, so the incidence a year after a tax is introduced is a different number from the incidence a decade later. The key models page of the masterclass lists the incidence formula with the other equations of the Foundation units, and the post on the 2018 tariffs applies the same logic to a tax at the border, where the answer surprised many people.


