The Economist's Toolkit
Economics studies how people and societies use scarce resources, and how millions of separate choices are coordinated through prices. This unit introduces the ideas every later unit uses (opportunity cost, incentives, the margin, equilibrium), the first two models of the subject, and the arithmetic of growth rates, index numbers, and real values. It ends with the question of how economists tell a cause from a correlation, worked through on a famous study of the minimum wage.
1 Introduction
Think about the cup of coffee that many readers have next to them. The beans grew on a hillside in Brazil, Vietnam, or Ethiopia and were picked by someone who will never know who drank them. A trader bought the sacks, a ship built in South Korea carried them, a roaster in another country heated them, a printer made the paper cup, and a dairy farm produced the milk. Nobody planned that this particular cup would be ready for you this morning, and nobody could have planned it, because the people involved speak different languages, live on four continents, and have never heard of one another. The coffee arrived because each of them was paid a price for their part of the work, and that price was enough to make the work worth doing. The economy is the largest cooperative undertaking that humans have ever built, and it is run by nobody.
Adam Smith (1723-1790) described the first half of this arrangement, the division of work among specialists, in 1776, using the example of a pin workshop he had visited. Ten men worked there, and each of them performed only a few of the eighteen operations that pin-making requires. Together they turned out more than 48,000 pins a day, whereas each of them working alone, Smith wrote, could hardly have made twenty. Specialization multiplies output, but it comes with a catch. A person who makes nothing but pin heads cannot eat pin heads, so specialists must trade, and trade among millions of strangers needs a way to tell everyone what is scarce and what is wanted, and prices do this. When a frost kills part of the Brazilian coffee crop, the price of beans rises within days, and roasters in Hamburg and Seattle economize on coffee without reading a single report about the weather in Minas Gerais, the Brazilian state where much of the crop grows. The price carries information that nobody collected in one place.
The photograph at the head of this unit shows how much depends on getting these arrangements right. It was taken from the International Space Station on 30 January 2014. The bright area is South Korea; the dark area north of it, between Seoul and the lights of China, is North Korea. The two countries were one until 1945. They share a language, a history of more than a thousand years, and a peninsula. South Korea’s economy, measured per person, was among the poorer ones in the world in 1960, below Ghana’s and Bolivia’s at the time, and is now on a par with the United Kingdom’s. By the figures NASA published with the picture, North Korea used about 739 kilowatt hours of electricity per person a year and South Korea 10,162, which is about 14 times as much. Geography, climate, and talent are the same on both sides of the line. What differs is how the two economies are organized, and the study of such arrangements, and of their consequences, is economics.
The questions of the subject are old and large. Why are some countries rich and others poor? What makes prices rise, and why does it hurt? Why does an economy that worked last year sometimes stop working, with factories idle and people who want jobs unable to find them, as happened across the world in 1930 and in 2009? Who really pays a tax? What does a central bank actually do when it “raises interest rates”? Economists do not agree on every answer, but the questions have definite shape, and some answers are known with confidence; since the 1990s economists have learned to answer causal questions with the care of a clinical trial, and the unit ends with one of those answers.
This masterclass takes you through the field in sixteen units, of which the first eight form the Foundation: how markets set prices, how buyers and firms decide, where markets fail, how the economy is measured, and why it grows. This first unit builds the toolkit that all of them use, which is a handful of ideas about choice, the arithmetic of growth and prices, the graphs of the subject, and the discipline of telling cause from correlation. None of it needs more than school mathematics.