Image: Jan Brueghel the Younger, Allegory of Tulip Mania (1640s), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
What is a share worth, and does the market know? This unit sets out the dividend discount model and the efficient markets hypothesis, shows with Robert Shiller's century of data that prices move far more than the dividends that follow can justify, and measures in brokerage records which of the biases of the earlier units survive when money is at stake. It explains why professional investors do not simply correct wrong prices, tells the famous bubbles from the tulips of 1637 to the house prices of 2006 as the records show them, and closes the program with the open questions of economics in 2026 and where to go next.
Preview: the beginning of the unit
On the evening of 5 December 1996, Alan Greenspan, then chairman of the Federal Reserve, the central bank of the United States, asked an after-dinner audience in Washington how a central bank could know “when irrational exuberance has unduly escalated asset values”. Share prices fell around the world the next day. Then they recovered, and the Nasdaq Composite, the index dominated by the technology shares that worried him most, went on to more than double before it peaked at 5,048.62 on 10 March 2000. Over the next thirty months it lost 78 per cent of its value, and it did not reach 5,048 again until April 2015. This unit asks what a share is worth, whether the market knows, which of the biases of the last three units survive where mistakes cost money, and what the famous bubbles looked like in the records rather than in the legends. As the last unit of the program, it ends with where economics stands in 2026 and where a reader can go next.
1 What a share is worth
A share is a claim on part of a company’s future profits, paid out as dividends or kept inside the company to be paid out later. Unit 9 showed that a payment of \(X\) due in \(t\) years is worth \(X/(1+i)^t\) today when money can be lent at the interest rate \(i\). A share is a bond whose payments are uncertain, so the standard model values it by replacing each certain payment with the payment that is expected, and the safe interest rate with a higher rate \(r\) that compensates the holder for bearing the uncertainty. The result is called the dividend discount model, and its constant-growth form is known as the Gordon growth model after Myron Gordon (1920-2010), who worked it out with Eli Shapiro in 1956 and made it the centre of his own work from 1959.
1.1 The efficient markets hypothesis
The model says what a share would be worth to an investor who knew the expected dividends. The market contains millions of investors with different information, and the question is what the price they agree on contains. In a review published in 1970 in the Journal of Finance, Eugene Fama, who was awarded the 2013 Nobel prize in economic sciences for this work together with Lars Peter Hansen and Robert Shiller, defined a market as efficient when prices “fully reflect” all available information, and sorted the claim into three forms by what counts as available.